The following is the Introduction to Authority, History, and Political Theology: Collected Works and Correspondence of Alexandre Kojève and Gaston Fessard by Isabel Jacobs and Jacob Saliba (eds) as published by Bloomsbury Academic, an imprint of Bloomsbury Publishing Plc, in August 2026. Permission to republish on Communis the full text of the editors’ Introduction, retitled for this occasion, has been granted by Bloomsbury Academic.

“In 1965, Gaston Fessard invited Alexandre Kojève to give a lecture at the Jesuit seminary of Chantilly, where Fessard was residing and teaching. He introduced his old friend to the audience, recounting tales from Kojève’s famed Hegel seminars of the 1930s. The lecture, entitled ‘The Structure and History of Philosophy,’ delivered by an atheist in a religious institution, stands as a final testament to the lifelong bond between the Hegelian and the Jesuit, while bringing their debate to a close.”
—Isabel Jacobs and Jacob Saliba

Introduction to Authority, History, and Political Theology: Collected Works and Correspondence of Alexandre Kojève and Gaston Fessard

There is no doubt that Alexandre Kojève’s thought, arising from his influential seminars on Hegel at the École Pratique des Hautes Études (EPHE) during the 1930s, left an indelible mark on philosophy and political theory throughout the twentieth century. His provocative concepts, most notably the “end of history,” have become defining tropes in contemporary theory. Kojève’s larger project was a secular and politically engaged update of Hegel’s philosophy for his own time. Among his students from the 1930s were luminaries including Raymond Aron, Georges Bataille, Maurice Merleau-Ponty, and Jacques Lacan. Beyond the seminars, Kojève gained notoriety for his debate with the German-Jewish political theorist Leo Strauss on tyranny and wisdom, itself a cornerstone of modern political philosophy.[1] Putting Strauss’s theory of esoteric writing into practice, their exchange unfolded not only in public eyes but also in private correspondence and reviews.[2] Yet, Strauss was neither Kojève’s only interlocutor nor necessarily his most important philosophical rival.

When the political philosopher Stanley Rosen recalled his encounter with Kojève in Paris in the 1960s, he noticed that Kojève often evoked one figure that stood above the rest of his circle: the theologian and Jesuit priest Gaston Fessard, “one of Kojève’s closest friends, perhaps his closest friend in Paris.”[3] Rosen, moreover, added that among everyone he met, including Paul Ricœur and Emmanuel Levinas, Fessard remained “in my view, the greatest”—with the exception of Kojève himself.[4] Though little-known in English-speaking scholarship, Fessard was a giant on the French scene.[5] He was known for his public debates with left-wing intellectuals, his resistance to Vichy in the 1940s, and pioneering contributions to the New Theology movement that led to the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s. Throughout, Fessard maintained a close dialogue with Kojève, his friend, teacher, and philosophical sparring partner. This volume is the first systematic collection of the published and unpublished materials that document their exchanges and debates, including letters, essays, book reviews, and lectures. Standing at the intersection of secular political thought and theological discourse, Kojève and Fessard radically reshaped concepts of authority, right, sovereignty, and the end of history. This volume reveals how each thinker developed an original reading of Hegel, and how those readings—and the debate that they spurred—continue to shape political theology today.[6]

Two Readers of Hegel

From the early 1930s until 1968, Kojève and Fessard developed a dialectical bond in which each saw the other as a necessary counterpart for reaching what Hegel called “absolute knowledge”—a stage of historical consciousness capable of synthesizing and reconciling all possible viewpoints. The tension between Christian theology and atheism was particularly useful to both thinkers in this pursuit. Their debate, rooted in divergent readings of Hegel, was centered around the limits and possibilities of a political theology for their own dark times. For nearly four decades, Kojève and Fessard discussed how Marxist-Hegelian concepts of freedom, propaganda, and revolution dialectically played on theological ideas of God, the Trinity, eschatology, grace, love, and divine sovereignty. This interplay would also have profound implications for the study of authority, law, and totalitarianism.[7]

Born in 1897, Fessard joined the novitiate of the Society of Jesus in 1913. After serving in the First World War, he returned to his studies for the priesthood.[8] Due to the Laws of Association (1901) and Laws of Separation (1905) secularizing education in France, Fessard was exiled to a scholasticate on the Channel Island of Jersey. From 1923 to 1926, Fessard returned to Paris to pursue a degree in law and philosophy at the University of Paris, completing a thesis on the eighteenth-century spiritualist philosopher Maine de Biran under the direction of Léon Brunschvicg. Soon after, Fessard moved to the Fourvière seminary in Lyon, where he completed his theological requirements and was ordained a priest in 1928.[9]

It was in Lyon in the late 1920s that Fessard was first exposed to Hegel’s philosophy through Jean Wahl, then teaching at the University of Strasbourg.[10] Fessard had acquired a copy of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit by chance at a Munich bookseller on a spiritual retreat in the summer of 1926.[11] Deeply immersed in the text, Fessard had by 1929 translated substantial portions of the Phenomenology, then available only in German, into French. Soon after, with Wahl’s encouragement, he proposed excerpts from his translation to the Revue philosophique, accompanied by a commentary on the Preface.[12] While the publication did not come to fruition, Wahl prompted Fessard to contact two Russian émigrés, Alexandre Koyré and Kojève, who, by coincidence, were also pursuing a translation of the Phenomenology.[13] In a letter to de Lubac, on July 23, 1934, Fessard recalls: “Without having thought about it much in advance, I told [Wahl] that I will take up again my Phenomenology.”[14]

Kojève, too, had arrived at the study of Hegel in his own way. Steeped in Buddhism and Russian thought from an early age, he wrote his doctoral thesis at the University of Heidelberg, supervised by Karl Jaspers, on the Russian religious philosopher Vladimir Solovyov.[15] Upon his arrival in Paris in 1926, Kojève regularly frequented Russian circles which included his friend Lev Karsavin, as well as leading religious thinkers such as Georges Florovsky and Nikolai Berdyaev.[16] His most important book before the Hegel seminar was Atheism (1931), a dense exploration of the paradoxical status of atheistic and theistic stances on the metaphysical foundations of reality.[17] In Atheism, Kojève specifically developed a unique conception of the atheistic position that goes beyond the mere negation of the existence of God, one that would resurface in his reading of Hegel.

Drawing from Heideggerian phenomenology, Buddhism, and Russian apophatic theology, Kojève’s self-critical atheism is grounded in a radical denial of any transcendence, embracing instead the finitude of human existence as an act of freedom. From the late 1920s, Kojève’s Hegelian adventures began under the tutelage of Koyré, who was teaching a seminar on Hegel’s religious thought at the EPHE, the very seminar that Kojève would take over in 1933. Those years saw the beginnings of Fessard and Kojève’s intellectual friendship. Initial contact between the Jesuit and the Hegelian was facilitated through Koyré. Summarizing a letter he received from Koyré, Fessard recounted to his friend de Lubac, on July 28, 1934:

My replacement at the École des Hautes Études, Mr. A. Kojevnikov has translated nearly the entire Introduction and Chapters I to IV (C to D, sixty pages more than me, at least if he also translated the Preface). I intend to continue this work, but if you already have a translation ready then it’s not necessary. If you intend to produce a complete translation of the Phenomenology, you can, if you wish, get in touch with Mr. Kojevnikov. . . . Should we contact Mr. Kojevnikov? In fact, I am ahead of him by having already translated the last eighty pages. But he is a guy who certainly knows his German ten times better than me. All I can hope for, it seems to me, is to build a good rapport with Koyré and take on a full translation together, where I would handle the religious and a few other interesting parts.[18]

All “the work I have done for myself for nearly five years,” Fessard lamented to his fellow Jesuit, “is now almost useless. I have to admit that I am quite maddened.”[19] That very same day, Fessard sent his first letter to Kojève stating his intention to collaborate on translating the Phenomenology. It was in this context that, soon after, Fessard was officially welcomed by Kojève to join the Hegel seminar in the autumn of 1934.[20] Upon Fessard’s entrance to the seminar, Kojève had just completed his commentary on the master-slave dialectic. By 1939, two other Jesuits would join as students: Henri Bouillard and “Fr. Hayen.”[21] Kojève’s most eager student, Fessard, did not miss a single seminar. Meanwhile, he also attended a writing session (séance de travail) with Kojève and Koyré, debating on one occasion how to translate the German terms Verstand and Vernunft in Hegel.[22]

While the collaborative translation ultimately fell through, a lifelong friendship was born. By the spring of 1935, Fessard sent Kojève a copy of his article “A Phenomenology of Existence” (1935), an essay on the tension between the categories of immanence and transcendence.[23] He was anxious to receive Kojève’s response. In a letter to de Lubac on March 9, 1936, he wrote: “Knowing that Kojevnikov wanted to read this article, I sent it to him. . . . No response for three weeks.”[24] At last, Kojève responded and their debate took off. Writing to Fessard in June, he stated that “among my listeners, you were undoubtedly one of the most competent, and perhaps the only one who—like me—took the text ‘seriously.’”[25] Fessard admired Kojève’s “activist and existential interpretation,” even in spite of “my stance on religious values” against “the a-religiousness that you recognize in [Hegel].”[26] Defending his Christian reading of Hegel against Kojève’s interpretation, Fessard challenged and reoriented some of his teacher’s central concepts. Was Kojève himself not Hegel’s apostle, reading the Phenomenology as his Bible? In the words of Livio Sichirollo, Kojève was “literally obsessed with the idea of God” throughout his life[.27]

The dialectical play between Hegelian science and Christian revelation, wisdom and religion, philosophy and theology, was central to the Hegel lectures. At stake for Kojève was an atheistic and anthropological reading of Hegel, one that immanentizes all eschatology, asserting that the end of time has already been realized on earth, here-and-now. Hegel’s system of knowledge, for Kojève, was a philosophy without God, marking the end of Christianity in atheism. Fessard, in contrast, insisted on the importance of a spiritually centered interpretation of Hegel, where God fully retains his divinity through his entrance into the finite order through the Incarnation. Kojève found in Hegel’s anthropology the absolute sublation—as both overcoming and intensification—of Christian theology:

Now, according to Hegel, one can realize the Christian anthropological ideal (which he accepts in full) only by “overcoming” Christian theology: Christian man can really become what he would like to be only by becoming a man without God—or, if you will, a God-Man. He must realize in himself what at first he thought was realized in his God. To be really Christian, he himself must become Christ.[28]

The history of Christianity, he states, is nothing but the history of realizing an ideal society in which every citizen would be perfectly satisfied. This state could only be realized once all transcendence was eliminated and Heaven brought back to Earth. Absolute knowledge at the end of history thus “has the same content as Christian Theology, minus the notion of transcendence.”[29] To deny God, as Kojève insisted from Atheism to his late writings, is to embrace the possibility of humans themselves transforming the world and achieving wisdom on earth. While God is outside of time, humans can only act within time. Yet, as Fessard was eager to show, this position is undermined by the fact that atheism is grounded in nothing beyond itself—nothing being as philosophically elusive and difficult to conceptualize as radical alterity and transcendence.

The Outstretched Hand: Politics and Religion

By the mid-1930s, the growing tension between fascism and communism forced theology into a position where it could no longer avoid making a political choice. Sensitive to this, Fessard published two books in response, Pax Nostra: Examen de conscience international [Pax Nostra: International Examination of Conscience] (1936) and La main tendue: Le dialogue catholique-communiste est-il possible? [The Outstretched Hand: Is Catholic-Communist Dialogue Possible?] (1937). The Outstretched Hand explicitly addressed whether or not—and how—a Christian can oppose fascism and join forces with communism.[30] Fessard was drawn to the Resistance, yet considered its reliance on atheistic materialism theologically untenable. Kojève’s review of both books in 1936/37 would become the first piece of writing where he explicitly took up Fessard’s theological system, calling into question the grounds of Christianity’s claim of going beyond mythic character in an age organized by secular politics.[31] Whereas Pax Nostra aimed to recover the Pauline theology of universal reconciliation, The Outstretched Hand engaged more rigorously in contemporary debates over Hegel, Marxism, and Christianity.[32]

The book was inspired by Kojève’s reading of Hegel, which Fessard adapted to a Christian conception of history, aiming to “correct” Kojève’s notion of the end of history through St. Paul’s universalism.[33] Where Kojève strove for a heaven on earth, Fessard’s utopia of divine salvation sought to raise a fallen world toward its final redemption in heaven.[34] The title itself, The Outstretched Hand, nods to a radio talk by Maurice Thorez, chairman of the French Communist Party, which called for communists to work alongside Catholics in the fight against fascism.[35] Fessard argued that communism was fundamentally torn between the openness to religion in the humanist Marx (and, by extension, the early Hegel) and the atheistic materialism promoted by the Bolsheviks.[36] According to Fessard, a rapprochement between Catholicism and communism could only be achieved if communists accepted Marxist humanism.[37]

Responding to Fessard’s attempt at a Christian Hegel, Kojève took up similar issues in a book review on Fr. Auguste Grégoire. With a typical hint of irony, Kojève’s review examines the attempt to prove the existence of God through metaphysical causality.[38] Following Atheism and the Hegel lectures, Kojève contends that the tension between theology and atheism is not resolvable through reason alone but requires a practical decision. In Kojève’s political atheism, it was Hegel who immanentized a transcendent God by proclaiming Napoleon’s empire as “the realization of the Christian Kingdom of heaven” on earth.[39] Where Kojève insisted on immanentizing Hegel’s philosophy, Fessard preserved transcendence within Hegel’s philosophy of history, a stance he reaffirmed in his 1938 lecture, “Revolution and Persecution,” given at Gabriel Marcel’s soirée, with Kojève and Aron in attendance.[40] The presentation set out to examine the Christian attitude toward revolution and persecution, triangulating Kojève’s reading of the master-slave dialectic with his own concepts of recognition and the common good.

Kojève saved his remarks on Fessard’s presentation for the next session of the Hegel seminar at which time they actually debated. As Fessard later observed to de Lubac: “Following my lecture at Marcel’s, where Kojevnikof had come, he refuted me during the course at Hautes Études and then gave me the floor . . . I think I got him quite well . . . a revenge that I earned, as much for my assiduity as for my patient and respectful silence for four years!”[41] Finally, in the last session of the Hegel seminar in May 1939, Kojève selected his favorite students, Fessard and Aron, to each voice their critique, serving as the final student presentations of the seminar.[42] While Aron drew on ideas from his recently published Introduction to the Philosophy of History: An Essay on the Limits of Historical Objectivity (1938),[43] Fessard chose to attack Kojève’s atheistic Hegel by reframing the metaphysical triad of Logic, Nature, and History. “If I am not mistaken,” Fessard recalls, “my most serious objection to that of our common master was based on the priority of the dialectic of Here and Now over that of Master and Slave.”[44] He argued further that Kojève maintained the circularity of Hegel’s system “only in an artificial and imaginary way by his recourse to the sole image of the circumference without a center.”[45] Hegel’s triad of Logic, Nature, and History, according to Fessard, culminates in a dialectic of love. This dialectic was not simply a submission to traditional dogma on the theological virtue of charity but rather a political theory of Trinitarian reciprocity.[46] It was the Second World War that, in Hegelian terms, would become the world-historical stage on which a heightened battle of certain philosophical concepts would be played out.

Authority and Political Theology in Times of War

After the Munich Agreement in 1938, Kojève and Fessard’s positions converged in their commitment to take an active stand against Nazism. While their earlier debate from the 1930s was mainly concerned with radical atheism versus Catholic Hegelianism, the tone shifted during the 1940s to problems of tyranny, propaganda, and the violation of law.[47] Their respective concepts of authority, developed in response to the German occupation and Marshal Pétain’s regime, expressed an urgent existential need to reflect on the implications of totalitarianism for Hegelian philosophy. Initially stationed in Rueil, Kojève was drafted in 1940 but soon lost his unit close to Paris.[48] In 1941, he moved to Marseille, where he completed, in May 1942, The Notion of Authority (published posthumously).[49] The book provides a critical analysis of Judeo-Christian conceptions of divine authority. In a theological framework, God is seen as an eternal and divine first cause, the creator of the world. According to Kojève, political theology, however, can only account for one type of authority: the father. Where scholastic metaphysics explores the authority of the divine father, Hegel’s Phenomenology examines the authority of a this-worldly master over the slave. In fact, Kojève added two more types of authority to his schema: the leader and the judge, both of which pose the secular challenge of establishing law and politics without God.

For Fessard, a response to fascism and war required what he called in the Jesuit clandestine journal Témoignage chrétien [Christian Witness] “the weapons of the spirit.”[50] Like his confrères Pierre Chaillet, SJ, Yves de Montcheuil, SJ, and Michel Riquet, SJ, Fessard participated in Jesuit networks within the Resistance.[51] For example, under the pseudonym Monsieur X, Fessard wrote multiple pamphlets against the Nazis.[52] For him, the legitimacy of a political leader crucially rested on their ability to actualize the common good of the people rather than their own self-interest. Where Kojève emphasized the process of recognition through a dialectic of master and slave, Fessard argued for recognition as universal love and charity (a true re-co-naissance).[53] Building on the dialectic of man and woman, as a dialectic of unity through difference, Fessard eroticized Kojève’s reading of Hegel, developing the notion of a divine feminine, with an ultimate sublation (Aufhebung) of the sexual dialectic in love.[54]

Kojève also made contact with the French Resistance. Through his partner Nina Ivanoff, he met Léon Poliakov and even took part in activities in 1942, entrusted with gathering information and distributing underground pamphlets. Kojève’s political activity during the war, however, was politically ambiguous. He formed multiple alliances across political camps, including Pétain’s government, Resistance groups, and even the Soviet government.[55] In the summer of 1943, he stayed in the village of Gramat, where he wrote Outline of a Phenomenology of Right, published posthumously as an essential contribution to legal philosophy and political theory.[56] Kojève criticized the anarchist and anti-state tendencies in the Resistance, juxtaposing their libertarian politics with his own vision of the universal and homogeneous state, which would become a central idea in his political thinking after the war.

Also with an eye to the post-war order, Fessard asserted in his essay “Autorité et bien commun” [“Authority and the Common Good”] (1944)—via Schmitt’s theory of the state of exception—that authority is a specifically historical process in which the crisis of liberalism created the preconditions for a new world of sovereignty.[57] The sovereign who decides the exception, for Fessard, is the one who sacrifices themselves for the good of the people. Authority as a politics of martyrdom has thus no better representative than the Passion of Christ.[58] In France, prends garde de perdre ton ame! [France, Take Care Not To Lose Your Soul!] (1941), Fessard chastised Catholics who saw Pétain as their legitimate leader when, in fact, he was only a blind puppet to another tyrant.[59] The text performed a theological intervention into Hegel’s political philosophy, captured in the symbol of the circle, representing the closure and unity of time. Another pseudonymous reflection on the Hegelian foundations of authority,

Fessard’s France, prends garde de perdre ta Liberte! [France, Take Care Not To Lose Your Freedom!] (1945), fundamentally reshaped his theistic critique of Kojève.[60] Concerned that communists might only assert a materialist view of historical progress and social order after the war, Fessard argued that the realization of human freedom requires a theologically grounded source of authority in which salvation and social reconciliation must come from beyond the finite world.[61]

Political Theology After History

Toward the end of the war, which sparked new problems and reinforced old ones, Kojève and Fessard reignited their debate once more. Arrested by the Gestapo in March 1944, Kojève had managed to escape in spectacular fashion (not least thanks to his fluent German), reworking his experiences by “writing propaganda pamphlets in Russian, German, and Tatar to demoralize the German army and the Tatar and Russian soldiers who had first been taken prisoner and then incorporated into Hitler’s platoons.”[62] In December 1944, he returned to Paris. A year later, he was appointed to the Directorate of Foreign Economic Relations (DREE) by his former student Robert Marjolin, initiating his career in the upper echelons of the French administration. In July 1946, Kojève asked Fessard to meet.[63] Awaiting the release of Introduction to the Reading of Hegel with Gallimard, he published essays in Bataille’s newly founded journal Critique, within whose pages he called Fessard “the best theorist of Marxism in France.”[64] From the late 1940s until Kojève’s death in 1968, they corresponded extensively and reviewed each other’s books, offering at times veiled critiques by using another Catholic Hegelian, Henri Niel, as a cover.[65] The book review became the chosen genre of publicizing their debate on politics and religion.

By this time, it would seem that their intellectual friendship was only becoming stronger as their dialectical debate over political theology deepened. A mutual friend of both, Edmond Ortigues, recalled their friendship throughout the 1950s.[66] Together with Fessard and Fr. Henri Bouillard, the Jesuits would gather every couple of months chez Kojève, for dinner and philosophical-theological discussions—a tradition that lasted over a decade, despite Kojève’s frequent travels abroad for government work. Indeed, priests were among the few friends regularly welcomed into Kojève’s apartment, where conversations often continued late into the night.[67] On one of those soirées, Kojève, with his usual irony, revealed to his Jesuit friends why Sartre and Merleau-Ponty would never be able to understand his philosophy: “because they are not theologians!”[68]

After the war, Fessard wrote and taught extensively, delivering a lecture entitled “Hegel” to young seminarians in Mongré in 1948.[69] Fessard’s Hegel was a thinker of theological historicity, revealing how eternal time unfolds through history.[70] More precisely, Fessard situated Hegel between Marx and Kierkegaard, between temporal experience and the horizons of spiritual life.[71] In “The Problem of the End of History,” for example, he argued that Kojève’s own subtlety on this question lies not just in his conceptualization of a universal and homogeneous state, but in showing that history itself remains a volatile “pre-history” unless grounded in a transcendent order, namely, the infinite, or in religious terms, the eternal.[72] Updating his work from the 1930s and 1940s, Fessard developed and articulated an interpretation of Hegel and the early Marx that experimented with Catholic theology of the common good and secular theories of social action, freedom, and authority.[73]

Fessard’s own Hegel lecture would be channeled into his most well-known work, The Dialectic of the Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola.[74] Published in 1956, it argued that the development of consciousness operates like “a guide to action,” striving toward a summit where “Christ directs himself in ascension.”[75] For Fessard, Hegel fulfilled the conditions for action laid out in Ignatian spirituality while making explicit the political and historical structures through which freedom can be realized on both individual and social levels.[76] As Fessard explored in Dialogue théologique avec Hegel [Theological Dialogue with Hegel], written in the 1960s and published after his death, such an approach was a direct response to Kojève’s atheistic conclusions.[77] He states: “Hegel made me perceive in St. Paul a dialectic of the pagan and the Jew, while Kojève helped me grasp the importance of the master-slave dialectic, and through this, a dependance on Marx’s relationship to Hegel in terms of the end of history.”[78] By applying the master-slave dialectic to modern politics, he argued, Kojève left ambiguous how future historical progress should be understood.

On the holiest of days, Sundays, Kojève pursued what he called his “posthumous” work, a monumental update of the Hegelian System of Knowledge. During the week, he worked full-time as an economic adviser, a role he would continue until his death, facilitating large-scale international agreements in the midst of decolonization (e.g., the Évian Accords). His attempts at a philosophical system were as ambitious as his political career. Allan Bloom, who met Kojève for lunch in Paris in 1953, jokingly recalls how he sketched out his entire unfinished opus magnum on the sauce-stained tablecloth of a Vietnamese restaurant.[79] He worked relentlessly on a three-volume Attempt at a Reasoned History of Pagan Philosophy, an unfinished project that traces a new genealogy of Western philosophy, from the Pre-Socratics to Hegel, while dismantling the Judeo-Christian legacy.[80] Kojève’s Pagan Philosophy left a great impression on Jacob Taubes, a key figure in the study of political theology, eschatology, and Jewish mysticism, who enthusiastically read the manuscript.

Under the spell of Kojève’s Hegel, Taubes developed a post-Christian, eschatological view on history. Taubes first made contact with Kojève through a letter from July 5, 1955.[81] The letter reveals that Taubes gave a course at Harvard—“Hegel à la Kojève”—with great success and hundreds of students attending. Taubes later named his spring course “Introduction to Hegel’s Early Theological Writings (starting with St. Paul and ending with Marx).”[82] Liberally drawing on the published edition of Kojève’s lectures, often without crediting the author, Taubes presented a reading of Hegel as a transitional figure toward a post-Christian age of freedom.[83] He gave another seminar at Harvard, attended by Henry Kissinger, in 1953, lecturing on “Theology and Political Theory,” with reference to Kojève, Schmitt, de Lubac, Spinoza and Voegelin, while adding a spontaneous interpretation of the Gnostic passages in the Pauline Epistles.[84] In 1967, Taubes invited Kojève, whom he considered “the most important philosopher of that generation,” to give a talk at the Free University in West Berlin.[85] The lecture “What is Dialectics?” would be Kojève’s last before his death in 1968. From Berlin, Kojève immediately went to see Schmitt in Plettenberg: “Where else would you go in Germany? Carl Schmitt is the only one worth talking to.”[86] One cannot overstate the importance of the father of political theology to the Fessard-Kojève debate. Schmitt’s concepts of sovereignty, secularization, and law, as well as his critique of the bourgeois rational order, left traces in both Fessard’s and Kojève’s projects. While Fessard kept a library of Schmitt’s books (including one hand-signed copy), Kojève directly corresponded with Schmitt beginning in 1955.[87]

In 1965, Fessard invited Kojève to come out of bureaucratic life once more to give a lecture at the Jesuit seminary of Chantilly, where Fessard was residing and teaching.[88] He introduced his old friend to the audience, recounting tales from the famed Hegel seminars of the 1930s as well as calling the audience’s attention to Kojève’s eminent status among politicians and diplomats. The lecture, entitled “The Structure and History of Philosophy,” delivered by an atheist in a religious institution, stands as a final testament to the lifelong bond between the Hegelian and the Jesuit, while bringing their debate to a close.[89] Indeed, as Kojève wrote of Fessard, the question that remained “is to know which of the two must play the role of the master.”[90]

Notes

[1] Leo Strauss, On Revised and Expanded Edition. Including the Strauss-Kojève Correspondence, ed. Victor Gourevitch and Michael S. Roth (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2000). On the debate, see Timothy W. Burns and Bryan-Paul Frost (eds.), Philosophy, History, and Tyranny: Reexamining the Debate between Leo Strauss and Alexandre Kojève (Albany: State University of New York Press, 2016).

[2] Leo Strauss, Persecution and the Art of Writing (Chicago; London: The University of Chicago Press, [1952] 1988). Also see Alexandre Kojève, “Emperor Julian and his Art of Writing,” James H. Nichols, Jr., in Ancients and Moderns: Essays on the Tradition of Political Philosophy in Honor of Leo Strauss, ed. Joseph Cropsey (New York: Basic Books, 1964).

[3] Stanley Rosen, “Kojève’s Paris: A Memoir,” Parallax, 4 (1977): 4.

[4] Rosen, “Kojève’s Paris: A Memoir,” 8.

[5] The only English translation of Fessard’s work is his 1956 book, The Dialectic of the Spiritual Exercises of Ignatius of Loyola, trans. Oliva Blanchette and James Colbert (Boston: Brill, [1956] 2022).

[6] For an overview of recent debates in political theology, see Hent de Vries and Lawrence Sullivan (eds.), Political Theologies: Public Religions in a Post-Secular World (New York: Fordham University Press, 2006); The Power of Religion in the Public Sphere—Jürgen Habermas, Charles Taylor, Cornel West, Judith Butler, ed. Eduardo Mendieta and Jonathan VanAntwerpen (New York: Columbia University Press, 2011). Echoes of the Kojève-Fessard debate can also be found in Giorgio Agamben, Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life (Stanford: Stanford University Press, [1995] 1998); Miguel Vatter, Divine Democracy: Political Theology after Carl Schmitt (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2020).

[7] On the relation between Fessard and Kojève, see Marco Filoni, The Life and Thought of Alexandre Kojève (Evanston: Northwestern University Press, 2025); Danilo Scholz, “Alexandre Kojève et Gaston Fessard sur l’Autorité et la Politique,” Revue philosophique de la France et de l’étranger 141 (2016/3): 343–62; Stefanos Geroulanos, An Atheism That is Not Humanist Emerges in French Thought (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2010); Gaston Fessard, Hegel, Le Christianisme et l’Histoire, ed. Michel Sales (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1990); and Bernard Hesbois, Le livre et la mort: essai sur Kojève (Doctoral thesis, Université catholique de Louvain, 1985).

[8] On Fessard’s early Jesuit years, see Sarah Shortall, Soldiers of God in a Secular World: Catholic Theology and Twentieth-Century French Politics (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2021), 25–43; Sales, “Un philosophe chrétien engagé dans l’histoire de son temps,” in Fessard, Hegel, le Christianisme et l’Histoire, 17–19.

[9] Fessard is mostly known, alongside Henri de Lubac, for his role in New Theology, a twentieth-century reformist movement of Dominicans and Jesuits across Europe who contributed to the Second Vatican Council in the See Ana Petrache, Gaston Fessard, un chrétien de rite dialectique? (Paris: Les éditions du Cerf, 2017); Sarah Shortall, Soldiers of God in a Secular World; Hans Boersma, Nouvelle théologie and Sacramental Ontology: A Return to Mystery (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009); Jon Kirwan, An Avant-garde Theological Generation: The Nouvelle Theologie and the French Crisis of Modernity (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018); Jürgen Mettepenningen, Nouvelle Théologie—New Theology: Inheritor of Modernism, Precursor of Vatican II (New York: T&T Clark, 2010).

[10] Wahl importantly published one of the first books on the early Hegel in twentieth-century See Jean Wahl, Le Malheur de la conscience dans la Philosophie de Hegel (Paris: Rieder, 1929). On Fessard’s relationship to Wahl, see letter from Gaston Fessard to Henri de Lubac (April 10, 1930), Box 177/2, Fonds Michel Sales, Archives Jésuites.

[11] See Frédéric Louzeau, in Gaston Fessard, Autorité et bien commun: Aux fondements de la Société (Geneva: Ad Solem, 2015), 7. Also see Michel Sales, Gaston Fessard (1897–1978): Genèse d’une pensée (Brussels: Culture et verité, 1997),

[12] Ultimately, the text remained Initially, it was planned as part of a special issue on the occasion of the centenary of Hegel’s death. See Sales in Fessard, Hegel, le Christianisme et l’Histoire, 9; 246. On Wahl’s encouragement, see letter from Gaston Fessard to Alexandre Kojève (July 28, 1934), Fonds Kojève, NAF 28320 (Box 22, 1).

[13] See letter from Fessard to Henri de Lubac (July 23, 1934), Fonds Sales, 177/2, Archives Jésuites.

[14] See letter from Fessard to de Lubac (July 23, 1934), Fonds Sales, 177/2, Archives Jésuites.

[15] Alexandre Kojève, Die religioese Philosophie Wladimir Solowjews (Heidelberg, , Diss., 1926), doi:10.11588/diglit.41168 [as Alexander Koschewnikoff]. For his early essays on Solovyov, see Alexandre Kojève, The Religious Metaphysics of Vladimir Solovyov, trans. Ilya Merlin and Mikhail Pozdniakov (Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave-Macmillan, 2018).

[16] See Trevor Wilson, Alexandre Kojève and the Specters of Russian Philosophy (Evanston: Northwestern University Press, 2025).

[17] On Kojève’s atheism, see Hesbois, Le livre et la mort; Geroulanos, An Atheism That is Not Humanist Emerges in French Thought; also see Jeff Love’s excellent introduction in Alexandre Kojève, Atheism, Jeff Love (New York: Columbia University Press, 2018), as well as Trevor Wilson, “No More Godmen: Alexandre Kojève, Atheism, and Vladimir Solov΄ev,” Slavic Review 81, no. 4 (2022): 1016–36.

[18] Letter from Fessard to de Lubac (November 8, 1934), Fonds Sales, 177/2, Archives Jésuites.

[19] Letter from Fessard to de Lubac (November 8, 1934), Fonds Sales, 177/2, Archives Jésuites.

[20] See letter from Kojève to Fessard (November 10, 1934).

[21] The reference to Hayen comes from Fessard’s “Introduction to Alexandre Kojève’s Lecture at the Seminary of Chantilly” (February 6, 1965).

[22] Letter from Fessard to de Lubac (April 26, 1935), Fonds Fessard, 73/2, Archives Jésuites. Fessard also debated these concepts with Jean Wahl, Jean Hyppolite, Émile Bréhier, and the Belgian Jesuit Joseph Maréchal. See “Verstand-Vernunft chez Lettres Maréchal, Dhanis, Wahl, Bréhier, Méry, Hypolite, Soulhié,” Fonds Fessard, 29/H, Archives Jésuites.

[23] Gaston Fessard, “Une Phénoménologie de l’existence: La philosophie de M. R. Le Senne,” Recherches de science religieuse 25 (1935): 129–58. See “Appendix I” of this book.

[24] Letter from Fessard to de Lubac (March 9, 1936), Fonds Fessard, 73/2, Archives Jésuites.

[25] Letter from Kojève to Fessard (June 30, 1935), Fonds Sales, 177/2, Archives Jésuites.

[26] Letter from Fessard to Kojève (June 25, 1935), Fonds Sales, 177/2, Archives Jésuites.

[27] Livio Sichirollo, in Nina Ivanoff, Interview with Gnoli, Un hegeliano tra le tragedie del Novecento, in “la Repubblica,” 2 June 2002, 27.

[28] Alexandre Kojève, Introduction to the Reading of Hegel (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, [1947] 1980), 67.

[29] Kojève, Introduction to the Reading of Hegel, 73.

[30] See Gaston Fessard, Pax Examen de conscience international (Paris: Grasset, 1936); Fessard, La main tendue. Le dialogue catholique-communiste est-il possible? (Paris: Grasset, 1937).

[31] See Gabriel Marcel–Gaston, Fessard: Correspondance (1934–1971), presented and annotated by Henri de Lubac, Marie Gaugier and Michel Sales (Paris: Beauchesne, 1985), 506–16. Alexandre Kojève, “Review of Two Books by Gaston Fessard 1936/37,” Hugh Gillis. Interpretation: A Journal of Political Philosophy 19, no. 2 (Winter 1991–2): 188–92.

[32] Walter Benjamin critically reviewed Fessard’s La main tendue in 1938, focusing on Fessard’s concept of the “violence [Gewalt] of love” which realizes the Christian ideal of human In Christ’s incarnation [Fleischwerdung], the antinomy between materialistic and idealistic dialectic can be sublated. See Walter Benjamin, Gesammelte Schriften, Band 3, Kritiken und Rezensionen (Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, 1972), 552. On Fessard’s argument in Pax Nostra, see Shortall, Soldiers of God in a Secular World, 76–7.

[33] On reactions to Fessard’s La main tendue, including the communist Paul Nizan, see Geroulanos, An Atheism that Is Not Humanist Emerges in French Thought, 117–18; on the Catholic Church’s attitude, see Shortall, Soldiers of God in a Secular World, 65–6. In Fessard’s political theology, Saint Paul’s “Letter to the Romans” was a key text. Hager Weslati has emphasized how Giorgio Agamben, in The Time That Remains: A Commentary on the Letter to the Romans (2005), evoked Kojève’s reading of Hegel as an extension of Paul’s messianism, while overlooking Fessard’s contribution to political theology (see Hager Weslati, “Tyranny and Boredom,” Journal for Cultural Research 27, no. 2 (2023): 186).

[34] On Fessard and eschatology, see Stephen Smith, “Time and Eternity in the Nouvelle Théologie,” in Between Apocalypse and Eschaton: History and Eternity in Henri de Lubac (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2015). On the subtle eschatological differences between Fessard and fellow Jesuit thinkers, see Frédéric Louzeau, “Gaston Fessard et Henri de Lubac: leur différend sur la question du communisme et du progressisme chrétien (1945–1950),” Revue des sciences religieuses 84, 4 (2010): 517–43.

[35] On Thorez’s appeal to Catholicism, see John Hellman, “‘Left-Catholics’ and Communism in the Nineteen-Thirties,” Church History 45, 4 (1976): 507–23.

[36] The writings of the young Marx, for example, The Manuscripts of 1844, were only just translated into French in On the French reception of the early Marx, see Tony Judt, Marxism and the French Left: Studies on Labour and Politics in France, 1830–1981 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1986), 179–81.

[37] In this regard, Fessard anticipates later debates on Marxist humanism that became more pronounced in the 1950s and 1960s, both in France and socialist Eastern Europe.

[38] Alexandre Kojève, “Immanence and transcendence” (1939), Isabel Jacobs and Kyle Moore, Continental Philosophy Review (2025).

[39] Alexandre Kojève, Introduction to the Reading of Hegel (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, [1947] 1980), 67.

[40] Gaston Fessard, “Revolution and Persecution: The Principle of a Political Decision.” Also, see Michel Sales, Gaston Fessard: Genèse d’une pensée, 57; also, see Gaston Fessard, La philosophie historique de Raymond Aron, Michel Sales (Paris: Julliard, 1980), 167.

[41] Letter from Fessard to de Lubac (June 4, 1938), Fonds Fessard, 73/2, Archives Jésuites.

[42] See Gaston Fessard, “Preparatory Notes for a Presentation at the Final Session of the Hegel ”

[43] See Raymond Aron, Introduction to the Philosophy of History: An Essay on the Limits of Historical Objectivity, George Irwin (Boston: Beacon Press, 1961 [1938]).

[44] Fessard, La philosophie historique de Raymond Aron, 167, 1.

[45] Fessard, La philosophie historique de Raymond Aron.

[46] This method of circularity would only become more pronounced by the time of The Dialectic of the Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola (1956).

[47] No letters from that period are preserved; on Fessard and Kojève in the 1940s, see Filoni, The Life and Thought of Alexandre Kojève; Scholz, “Alexandre Kojève et Gaston Fessard sur l’autorité et la politique”; also see Stefanos Geroulanos, “Heterogeneities, Slave-Princes, and Marshall Plans: Schmitt’s Reception in Hegel’s France,” Modern Intellectual History 8 (2011): 531–60.

[48] For a detailed account of Kojève’s short-lived military career, see Filoni, The Life and Thought of Alexandre Kojève, 156f.

[49] Alexandre Kojève, The Notion of Authority (A Brief Presentation), Hager Weslati (New York: Verso, 2020).

[50] Fessard was one of the journal’s founders and most active The term “weapons of the spirit” was first coined by his friend and colleague in the Jesuit resistance, Pierre Chaillet. See “Collaboration et fidelité,” Cahiers du Témoignage chrétien (October–November 1942), 10–11; reprinted in La résistance spirituelle, 1941–1944: Les Cahiers clandestins du Témoignage chrétien, ed. François and Renée Bédarida (Paris: Albin Michel, 2001), 190. On Fessard and anti-fascism, see Jean-Luc Marion, “Pierre Chaillet et Gaston Fessard: L’histoire et les idoles,” Communio (2024): 187–96; Frédéric Louzeau (and Gaston Fessard), L’anthropologie sociale du Gaston Fessard: suivi de Gaston Fessard, SJ, Collaboration et résistance au pouvoir du prince-esclave (octobre-décembre 1942) (Paris: Presses universitaires de France, 2009).

[51] On the Jesuits and resistance to fascism, see Shortall, Soldiers of God in a Secular World, 87–113; La résistance spirituelle, 1941–1944: Les Cahiers clandestins du Témoignage chrétien.

[52] Rosen, “Kojève’s Paris: A Memoir,” 8.

[53] See Fessard, “Revolution and Persecution.”

[54] The divine female figure of wisdom, Sophia, is also a foundational principle in modern Russian religious philosophy, in particular in Solovyov’s sophiology with which Kojève was intimately See Alexandre Kojève, Sophia, Tome 1: Philosophie et phénoménologie (Paris: Gallimard, 2025).

[55] See Scholz, “Alexandre Kojève et Gaston Fessard.” For his alleged “letter to Stalin,” see Kojève, Sophia, Tome 1.

[56] Kojève, Outline of a Phenomenology of Right (Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield, 2007).

[57] Fessard, Autorité et bien commun.

[58] See Fessard, Autorité et bien commun, 50–65.

[59] Fessard, France, prends garde de perdre ton âme! (Premier clandestin du Témoignage chrétien, 1941). By this time, Fessard’s theological work was considered avant-garde, if not controversial, in high-level Church circles for his promotion of an anti-fascist agenda that was sharply critical of Catholic complicity with the Vichy His 1939 Épreuve de Force [Moment of Truth] was banned under Nazi occupation in France, as was “Authority and the Common Good,” hence the need to publish under a pseudonym and in a clandestine journal. See Eugen Weber, Action Francaise: Royalism and Reaction in Twentieth-Century France (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1962); Robert Paxton, Vichy France: Old Guard and New Order, 1940–1944 (New York: Knopf, 1972); John Hellman, The Knight-Monks of Vichy France: Uriage, 1940–1945 (Montreal: McGill University Press, 1993).

[60] Fessard, France, prends garde de perdre ta Liberté! (Témoignage chrétien, 1945).

[61] On this productive period in Fessard’s career, see Sales, Gaston Fessard (1897–1978). Gaston Fessard, Mystère de la Société. Recherches sur le sens de l’Histoire, by Michel Sales (Namur: Culture et Vérité, 1997).

[62] Filoni, The Life and Thought of Alexandre Kojève, 224.

[63] Kojève’s request to meet with Fessard is reiterated in Fessard’s response in December 1946, at which time he admits having missed Kojève’s letter earlier in the See Letter from Fessard to Kojève (December 19, 1946).

[64] Alexandre Kojève, “Christianity and Communism,” Hugh Gillis. Interpretation: A Journal of Political Philosophy 19, no. 2 (Winter 1991–2), 192–5.

[65] See Alexandre Kojève, “Hegel, Marx, and Christianity” (1946) and Gaston Fessard, “Review of Henri Niel, On Mediation in Hegel’s Philosophy” (1946).

[66] See Edmond Ortigues, Sur la philosophie et la Les entretiens de Courances (Rennes: Presses Universitaires de Rennes, 2003), 75–83.

[67] On Kojève’s meetings with the Jesuits in the post-war era, see Marco Filoni, The Life and Thought of Alexandre Kojève; on Kojève and Ortigues, see Marco Filoni, “Dio, mio collega,” in Kojève mon ami (Turin: Nino Aragno Editore, 2013), 23–7; also see Edmond Ortigues, Sur la philosophie et la religion: Les entretiens de Courances, 75–83; “Pour l’honneur d’Alexandre Kojève,” Le Monde (October 4, 1999).

[68] Cited in Filoni, “Dio, mio collega,” 24.

[69] For this text, see “Part II: Lectures” of this book.

[70] Fessard’s The Dialectic of the Spiritual Exercises contained two more volumes that expand in scope and theme, stretching from sin and orthodoxy to symbolism and See Fessard, La Dialectique des “Exercises spirituels” de saint Ignace de Loyola, t. II, Fondement, Péché, Orthodoxie (Paris: Aubier, 1966); La Dialectique des “Exercises spirituels” de saint Ignace de Loyola, t. III, Symbolisme et Historicité (Paris: Lethielloux, 1984).

[71] See Fessard, “Dialogue thélogique avec Hegel,” in Sales, Hegel, le christianisme, et l’histoire, 27–33.

[72] “Appendix II” of this book.

[73] Gaston Fessard, “Hegel. Cours donné à Mongré avril–mai 1948,” Fonds Fessard, 113, Archives Jésuites.

[74] Gaston Fessard, The Dialectic of the Spiritual Exercises of Ignatius of Loyola.

[75] Fessard, The Dialectic of the Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola, 4–5. Also, on Fessard’s method in the dialectic of the spiritual exercises, see Matthew Ashley, “Shorter Notices: Fessard, SJ, Gaston: The Dialectic of the Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola,” Theological Studies (2023); Ana Petrache, “Dialectic as a Philosophical Pilgrimage: Spiritual Exercises as Political Theology in the Works of Gaston Fessard, S.J,” in Philosophy as a Spiritual Exercise: Contributions of the Society of Jesus to the Discipline of Philosophy, ed. Andrew Barrette, Jeffrey Bloechl, and Patrick Byrne (Chestnut Hill: Institute of Jesuit Sources, 2024); Jacques Servais, “Jorge Bergoglio and the Theologians Who Shaped his Reading of the Spiritual Exercises” Gregorianum 99 (2018): 483–507.

[76] Fessard, The Dialectic of the Spiritual Exercises of Ignatius of Loyola, 6–7.

[77] This text by Fessard was edited and published posthumously by Michel See Gaston Fessard, “Dialogue théologique avec Hegel.”

[78] See Fessard, “Dialogue théologique avec Hegel,” 27–8.

[79] See Allan Bloom, “Kojève, le philosophe,” Commentaire 9 (1980): 116.

[80] Only the first volume was published during Kojève’s lifetime, see Essai d’une histoire raisonnée de la philosophie païenne. Vol. 1: Les Présocratiques (Paris: Gallimard, 1968). For volumes two and three, see Alexandre Kojève, Essai d’une histoire raisonnée de la philosophie païenne. Vol. 2: Platon–Aristote (Paris: Gallimard 1972); Essai d’une histoire raisonnée de la philosophie païenne. Vol. 3: La Philosophie hellénistique. Les Néo-platoniciens (Paris: Gallimard, 1973).

[81] Letter from Taubes to Kojève (July 5, 1955) Box 22/ 2, Fonds Kojève, Bibliothèque nationale de France.

[82] Jerry Muller, Professor of Apocalypse: The Many Lives of Jacob Taubes (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2022),

[83] The course was attended by Susan Sontag, who took extensive notes and even became Taubes’s assistant.

[84] Muller, Professor of Apocalypse, 196.

[85] Jacob Taubes, “1948–1978: Thirty Years of Refusal,” in To Carl Schmitt: Letters and Reflections, Keith Tribe (New York: Columbia University Press, 2013), 52.

[86] Muller, Professor of Apocalypse, 340.

[87] Alexandre Kojève and Carl Schmitt, “Correspondence,” Interpretation: A Journal of Political Philosophy 29, 1 (Fall 2001): 91–115. On Fessard’s collection of Schmitt, see “Tirés-à-part de Carl Schmitt et de son groupe, avec des notes de G. Fessard” (box 77), Fonds Fessard, Archives Jésuites. Fessard also received a hand-signed copy of Der Staat als Mechanismus bei Hobbes und Descartes (1937) from Schmitt himself.

[88] See letter from Fessard to Kojève (January 18, 1965). Also, see Alexandre Kojève, “The Structure and History of Philosophy.”

[89] After the passing of Kojève, Fessard’s writings on theology and politics cut across new terrain, including the relationship between Catholicism and Islam. He corresponded with Claude Lévi-Strauss and publicly debated with Herbert Marcuse. See La Dialectique des “Exercises spirituels” de saint Ignace de Loyola, III, Symbolismeet Historicité, une correspondence inedité entre G. Fessard et Claude Lévi-Strauss (Paris: Éd. Lethielleux, 1984); “Dialogue avec Herbert Marcuse aux recontres internationale de Genève (September 1969),” in La Liberté et l’Ordre social (Neuchatel: La Baconnière, 1970); Fessard, “Islam et Amitiés islamo-chrétiennes,” Fonds Fessard, 7/49, Archives Jésuites.

[90] See Kojève, “Review of Two Books by Gaston Fessard.”

Feature image:  Alexandre Kojève. Photocomposition by Literary Hub.

,

Related